Why the armor of Roman legionnaires did not protect arms and legs

  • Apr 27, 2021
Why the armor of Roman legionnaires did not protect arms and legs
Why the armor of Roman legionnaires did not protect arms and legs

If you look at the images of Roman legionaries and photographs of reenactors, you will notice that the armor of the ancient state does not protect the arms and legs. A fair question arises as to why, with all their advancement by ancient standards, the Romans did not think of equipping their soldiers with such important elements of equipment as leggings and bracers?

All the Mediterranean peoples of antiquity knew how to protect their hands and feet. / Photo: goodfon.ru.
All the Mediterranean peoples of antiquity knew how to protect their hands and feet. / Photo: goodfon.ru.

This is because, standing on a hill, the famous reformer of the Roman legions, Gaius Marius, shouted: "Do not feel sorry for the legionnaires, the Romans are still giving birth!" But seriously, the absence protective equipment for arms and legs in the Roman legions had very specific rational reasons, dictated primarily by the tactics of fighting in the composition legion. In fact, the Romans were quite advanced and knew very well about the means of protecting the legs and arms (just look at the same Roman gladiators). And most importantly, the slave economy of the ancient state, especially by the time of Lucius Cornelius Sulla (138-78 BC era), could well have provided the legions with greaves and elbow pads, if not completely, then at least in some representative quantity. But there was simply no need for all this.

instagram viewer

The Romans knew about the protection of hands and feet throughout their history. / Photo: wikibooks.org.

To fully understand the question, you need to delve a little into the history of military affairs of Ancient Rome. In fact, the entire history of the legions can be divided into three large periods: the period of the use of manipulative tactics, the period the use of cohort tactics and the period of gradual departure from cohort tactics, which began at the end of the Roman the state. We are interested in the first two, because in the last period the Roman army did not look at all like the brave legions well-known to everyone from the works of artistic culture.

The early Roman legions were not much different from the troops of their neighbors and actively used exactly the same protective equipment. / Photo: ya.ru.

The essence of manipulative tactics is based on two pillars: the division of the entire army into tactical units - maniples and the division of all maniples according to a sign of veterancy: gastats (young recruits, "elephants"), principles (experienced veterans, "grandfather") and triarii (the elite of the early Roman army, "Demobilization"). Although maniples were the forerunners of the cohorts, on the battlefield they acted completely differently. The early Roman army was not much different from the troops of its neighbors: the Etruscans, Carthaginians, Greeks. The Romans were also built with a continuous phalanx - a line in three rows of maniples. In front were recruits, behind them veterans, in the rear - the elite. This tactic, among other things, gave rise to the famous Roman proverb: "It came to the Triarii." Its significance should be obvious - we are talking about the fact that in some important matter everything went very badly and the positive outcome hangs literally by a thread.

However, gradually the military tradition of Rome changed. The long spear, the sarissa, was replaced by the short throwing spear, the pilum. / Photo: tforums.org.

It is important to understand that although the Roman phalanx was three-row and polynomial (in the form of maniples), it was still the same phalanx. Moreover, the very early legions still used the long spear as their main weapon. However, this gradually began to change. Primarily due to the fact that Rome was in a very good and at the same time unfortunate place. On the one hand, the position of the city on seven hills was very favorable in terms of the economy, and on the other hand, it also made it a tasty morsel for all its neighbors. The Romans were forced to fight for protection, but at the same time they perfectly understood their position and had serious ambitions in the field of expansion. The bottom line is that they had to fight a lot.

The legionnaires were throwing spears more and more, rather than fighting them. / Photo: legio-x.ru.

And once you fight a lot, you inevitably lose a lot of people. The worst thing for any army is the veterans. The main trouble with manipulative tactics was what was the trouble with any other phalanx. They demanded a sufficiently high quality of fighters in terms of physical and drill training. Each new generation of recruits had to learn for a long time, and when you are in a state of war, there may simply not be time for this. As a result, the average quality of the army sags, and with it successes on the battlefield sag. Interestingly, just in the era of the Roman phalanx, legionnaires perfectly used greaves (they usually wore one on the leading left leg, put forward in formation) and elbow pads. However, this era was receding into the past.

Due to the impossibility of regularly and quickly training all recruits to the desired level of quality, the Romans began to give more and more preference to remote combat - throwing darts. A gradual shift from the use of long spears in favor of several throwing short ones began. This is because to throw a dart you no longer need to be as strong and enduring as to handle a long spear. Demanding on the rigor of holding the line is also reduced.

Early legions with manipulative tactics were built in one three-tiered formation, consisting of a large number of small detachments (manipuli), later legions were built in large detachments (cohorts) and not necessarily in one common inseparable build. / Photo: novate.ru.

And then gradually the Romans came to the tactics of cohorts, which finally took shape during the time of Sulla and the reforms of Guy Maria (157-86 BC). The Roman manipulative phalanx is finally a thing of the past. It was replaced by cohorts, which were no longer necessarily built on the field in one line. Gone is the three-member division of cohorts according to the principle of veterancy. Now there were just legionnaires. The cohorts included both recruits and veterans, as well as Evocats (legionnaires who retired, but then returned to serve on a contract). And all this became possible due to the fact that the main weapon of the legionnaire was not a sword or a spear, but a throwing dart - we saw. And at the same time, the need for close combat has disappeared.

The legions so well known to us from films and games relied heavily on ranged combat. / Photo: Pinterest.

Of course, the legionnaires fought hand-to-hand anyway. However, most of the battles were by no means the carnage that modern people are used to seeing in films. Moreover, the cohorts in every possible way helped the enemy "make the right decision" by throwing darts in his direction. Nevertheless, it is important to understand that the hand-to-hand combat of the later legionnaires was already far from the same consistency, frequency and fierceness, that hand-to-hand combat of early legionnaires, who, in their logic (form of application), differed little from the same Greek hoplites.

READ ALSO: 8 movie bloopers that are allowed in the image of medieval war, although historians have denied them

The tactics of the cohorts finally took shape during the civil war in Rome under Guy Mary and Cornelius Sulla. / Photo: livejournal.com.

Hence the answer to the main question posed at the beginning: there was simply no urgent need for the protective elements of arms and legs for most soldiers. And therefore the ubiquity of their use is a thing of the past. At the same time, in many antique images, greaves and elbow pads can often be seen at the tactical commanders of the legion - centurions and Roman standard-bearers - aquilifers. Moreover, probably some individual legionnaires from among the most worried about their health they spent the money they earned not on beer and prostitutes, but on the purchase of additional items equipment. Although the Roman legion was a big step for humanity on the way to creating a regular army (and in many ways it was), it was still an ancient army. Therefore, there was no exceptionally strict regulation on the form of clothing in it, and such amateur performance was not prohibited.

>>>>Ideas for life | NOVATE.RU<<<<

Close combat in the legion received less and less attention, and therefore greaves and sleeves became predominantly the lot of wealthy veterans and officers. / Photo: playground.ru.

Continuing the topic, you can read about how they lived gladiators in ancient Rome: whether they had a chance to survive in the arena.
A source:
https://novate.ru/blogs/041020/56261/